ETFdb Logo
ETFdb Logo
  • ETF Database
  • Channels
    • Active ETF
    • Beyond Basic Beta
    • China Insights
    • Climate Insights
    • Commodities
    • Core Strategies
    • Crypto
    • Direct Indexing
    • Disruptive Technology
    • Energy Infrastructure
    • ETF Building Blocks
    • ETF Education
    • ETF Strategist
    • Financial Literacy
    • Fixed Income
    • Gold/Silver/Critical Minerals
    • Innovative ETFs
    • Institutional Income Strategies
    • Leveraged & Inverse
    • Managed Futures
    • Market Insights
    • Modern Alpha
    • Night Effect
    • Portfolio Strategies
    • Responsible Investing
    • Retirement Income
    • Richard Bernstein Advisors
    • Tax Efficient Income
    • Volatility Resource
  • Tools
    • ETF Screener
    • ETF Country Exposure Tool
    • ETF Sector Tracker Tool
    • ETF Database Categories
    • Head-To-Head ETF Comparison Tool
    • ETF Stock Exposure Tool
    • ETF Issuer Fund Flows
    • Indexes
    • Mutual Fund To ETF Converter
  • Research
    • ETF Education
    • Equity Investing
    • Dividend ETFs
    • Leveraged ETFs
    • Inverse ETFs
    • Index Education
    • Index Insights
    • Top ETF Sectors
    • Top ETF Issuers
    • Top ETF Industries
  • Webcasts
  • Themes
    • AI ETFs
    • Blockchain ETFs
    • See all Thematic Investing ETF themes
    • ESG Investing
    • Marijuana ETFs
  • Multimedia
    • ETF 360 Video Series
    • ETF of the Week Podcast
    • ETF Prime Podcast
    • Video
  • Company
    • About VettaFi
    • Get VettaFi’ed
  • PRO
    • Pro Content
    • Pro Tools
    • Advanced
    • FAQ
    • Pricing
    • Free Sign Up
    • Login
  1. Active vs. Passive ETFs: What’s the Best Bet?
News
Share

Active vs. Passive ETFs: What’s the Best Bet?

Justin KuepperAug 17, 2015
2015-08-17

The debate between active and passive investing has raged on for decades, with no end in sight. While many studies have shown that actively managed exchange-traded funds underperform the market, new products are constantly being introduced in an attempt to change those trends, while academic research suggests that the markets aren’t quite as efficient as early research has suggested.

In this article, we’ll take a look at the active versus passive debate when it comes to ETFs and highlight some important considerations for investors.

Can You Beat the Market?

The Efficient Market Hypothesis (“EMH”) states that it’s impossible to “beat the market” because share prices always reflect all relevant information. Since stocks are always trading at their fair value, it’s impossible for investors to either purchase undervalued stocks or sell overvalued stocks in order to gain a competitive edge. The only way to generate above-market returns would be to purchase riskier investments with the risk-adjusted returns equal.

Active fund managers believe there are imperfections in the financial markets that create opportunities to profit. For instance, behavioral economists point to cognitive biases like overconfidence, information bias, and overreactions, which may create mispricing and opportunities in the market. Evidence of these biases can be seen in stock market bubbles and intrinsically undervalued stocks.


Content continues below advertisement

A Look at the Evidence

picture of stock market tickers

Researchers have found empirical evidence that has generally discredited strong forms of the EMH by showing that low P/E stocks tend to outperform without a corresponding high beta, although some argue that beta may not fully account for all risk factors. For instance, a stock may have a very low beta, but the lack of liquidity in the security could create a substantial risk that is reflected in the form of a lower “undervalued” share price.

On a more practical level, S&P Capital IQ and S&P Dow Jones index researchers found that only 8% to 16% of actively managed equity finds have beaten their benchmarks after fees over the past ten years. Fees impacted returns very little for equity funds – contrary to popular belief – but bond funds were heavily impacted. Actively managed large-cap value funds tended to outperform their passive peers, while small-cap and high-yield funds did not.

New Active Products

The poor performance of actively managed funds hasn’t stopped managers from trying a number of new strategies, including so-called “lightly managed” funds or funds based on academically supported strategies.

Smart Beta funds track an index like a passively managed fund, but employ tactical asset allocation algorithms like an actively managed fund. The goal is to move into better performing areas of an index at opportune times, while avoiding poor investments within an index. For instance, a Smart Beta fund might preferentially weight securities in the S&P 500 index based on their price-earnings ratio rather than their market capitalization.

Some actively managed funds are also taking advantage of well-studied dynamics, such as the Guggenheim Spin-Off ETF (CSD C), which invests in spin-offs. According to some studies, spin-offs tend to outperform the overall market in their first several years due to inefficiencies in the process, such as the mandatory selling of index funds that are forbidden from holding shares of smaller spin-offs not in the target index.

Key Takeaways

  • The debate between active and passive management has been raging for decades with no end in sight as new research and offerings change opinions.
  • Research has generally shown that there may be opportunities in the market, although most actively managed funds underperform their benchmarks.
  • ETF investors should generally prefer actively managed large-cap value ETFs, while sticking to passive ETFs for other asset classes – especially bonds.

» Popular Pages

  • Tickers
  • Articles

May 26

Main Management Market Note: May 26, 2023

May 26

Family Offices Embrace Crypto, While Needing Support

May 26

ETF Issuer League: Avantis, Summit Up, Global X

May 26

Active ETFs Positioned Better for Opportunities in High-Yield Bonds

May 26

Insurers Own Major Stakes in Fixed Income ETFs

May 26

Cash Flow Kings at Home With These ETFs

May 26

Counter U.S. Default Risk With Foreign Equity ETF AVDE

May 26

Vangaurd's EM Bond ETF Surprises With Fixed Income Protection

May 26

The Economy Matters: PCE, GDP, Durable Goods & Employment Numbers

May 26

SPYI Captures Huge Single Day Nvidia Pop, Enhances Income

QQQ

Invesco QQQ Trust

SPY

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

JEPI

JPMorgan Equity Premium...

VTI

Vanguard Total Stock Market...

VOO

Vanguard S&P 500 ETF

VGT

Vanguard Information...

TLT

iShares 20+ Year Treasury...

BND

Vanguard Total Bond Market...

XLP

Consumer Staples Select...

BOTZ

Global X Robotics &...


Content continues below advertisement

Loading Articles...
Our Sites
  • VettaFi
  • Advisor Perspectives
  • ETF Trends
Tools
  • ETF Screener
  • Mutual Fund to ETF Converter
  • Head-To-Head ETF Comparison
  • ETF Country Exposure Tool
  • ETF Stock Exposure Tool
  • ETF Database Pro
More Tools
  • Financial Advisor & RIA Center
Explore ETFs
  • ETF News
  • ETF Category Reports
  • Premium Articles
  • Alphabetical Listing of ETFs
  • Browse ETFs by ETF Database Category
  • Browse ETFs by Index
  • Browse ETFs by Issuer
  • Compare ETFs
Information
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
  • © 2023 VettaFi LLC. All rights reserved.

Advertisement

Is Your Portfolio Positioned With Enough Global Exposure?

ETF Education Channel

How to Allocate Commodities in Portfolios

Tom LydonApr 26, 2022
2022-04-26

A long-running debate in asset allocation circles is how much of a portfolio an investor should...

Core Strategies Channel

Why ETFs Experience Limit Up/Down Protections

Karrie GordonMay 13, 2022
2022-05-13

In a digital age where information moves in milliseconds and millions of participants can transact...

}
X