ETFdb Logo
ETFdb Logo
  • ETF Database
  • Channels
    • Active ETF
    • Beyond Basic Beta
    • China Insights
    • Climate Insights
    • Commodities
    • Core Strategies
    • Crypto
    • Direct Indexing
    • Disruptive Technology
    • Energy Infrastructure
    • ETF Building Blocks
    • ETF Education
    • ETF Strategist
    • Financial Literacy
    • Fixed Income
    • Gold/Silver/Critical Minerals
    • Innovative ETFs
    • Institutional Income Strategies
    • Leveraged & Inverse
    • Managed Futures
    • Market Insights
    • Modern Alpha
    • Multifactor
    • Night Effect
    • Portfolio Strategies
    • Responsible Investing
    • Retirement Income
    • Richard Bernstein Advisors
    • Tax Efficient Income
  • Tools
    • ETF Screener
    • ETF Country Exposure Tool
    • ETF Sector Tracker Tool
    • ETF Database Categories
    • Head-To-Head ETF Comparison Tool
    • ETF Stock Exposure Tool
    • ETF Issuer Fund Flows
    • Indexes
    • Mutual Fund To ETF Converter
  • Research
    • ETF Education
    • Equity Investing
    • Dividend ETFs
    • Leveraged ETFs
    • Inverse ETFs
    • Index Education
    • Index Insights
    • Top ETF Sectors
    • Top ETF Issuers
    • Top ETF Industries
  • Webcasts
  • Themes
    • AI ETFs
    • Blockchain ETFs
    • See all Thematic Investing ETF themes
    • ESG Investing
    • Marijuana ETFs
  • Multimedia
    • ETF 360 Video Series
    • ETF of the Week Podcast
    • ETF Prime Podcast
    • Video
  • Company
    • About VettaFi
    • Get VettaFi’ed
  • PRO
    • Pro Content
    • Pro Tools
    • Advanced
    • FAQ
    • Pricing
    • Free Sign Up
    • Login
  1. Active Management Is Difficult, but Can Play a Role
News
Share

Active Management Is Difficult, but Can Play a Role

Todd RosenbluthMay 02, 2022
2022-05-02

Consistently outperforming peers is hard because while skill plays a role in success, so does luck. This is true whether we’re talking about sports, where the ball needs to bounce in your favor, or active management in the stock market. The recently released Persistence Scorecard Year End 2021 by S&P Dow Jones Indices provides insights into why advisors and end clients have shifted toward index-based, broad market ETFs.

While 58% of the 175 active U.S. large-cap mutual funds that were in the top quartile in 2019 maintained their lofty status in 2020, only 6.9% (just 12 funds) continued to do so in 2021. Investors hoping for a repeat performance were better off if they focused on large-caps that were in the top half of the investment category in 2019, as 29% still outperformed two years later, but most failed to deliver. 

In S&P Dow Jones Indices’ analysis, the number of funds included is low, as the analysis avoided double counting multiple share classes by using data on the share class with the highest previous period return.

Not surprisingly, broad market large-cap index-based ETFs, including those tied to the S&P 500 Index, such as the iShares Core S&P 500 ETF (IVV A), the SPDR S&P 500 ETF (SPY A), and the Vanguard S&P 500 ETF (VOO A), as well as those tied to other benchmarks, like the iShares Russell 1000 ETF (IWB A) and the Vanguard Large Cap ETF (VV A-), have gained traction in recent years.

There’s a long-held belief that active management should be more successful in the land of small-caps, as some teams have the ability to find hidden gems among the more moderately sized and less-followed securities. However, the data does not back this belief up. 

Indeed, while 57% of the 122 top quartile U.S. small-cap funds in 2019 repeated their success in 2020, a miniscule 0.8% (just one) could claim the crown in 2021. The math is somewhat better when broadening out the universe to top half performers from 2019, as 9.4% of these funds were ahead of the peer average, but still nearly nine in 10 small-cap funds were unable to outperform for three consecutive years.

Small-cap ETFs, including those tied to the S&P Small Cap 600 Index, such as the iShares Core S&P Small Cap ETF (IJR A-), the iShares Russell 2000 ETF (IWM A-), and the Vanguard Small-Cap ETF (VB A), have swelled in size over the years as advisors seek out alternatives to active equity mutual funds.

With all of this data supporting using broad market index-based products for U.S. equity exposure, you might be wondering whether I am the same person who wrote on this platform about the potential in general for active equity ETFs and more narrowly constructed thematic ETFs in recent weeks. To answer: Why yes, I am, and I appreciate you reading my content.

Advisors can build portfolios that combine low-cost core equity exposure using some of the above products with active and/or thematic ETFs such as the ARK Innovation ETF (ARKK B+) and the JPMorgan Equity Premium Income (JEPI A), in an effort to generate stronger potential returns, while mitigating the risk of possible underperformance through diversification benefits. 

Active and index ETFs can work together to help advisors and their clients strive for outperformance in a risk-managed way.

To see more of Todd’s research, reports, and commentary on a regular basis, please subscribe here.

For more news, information, and strategy, visit ETF Trends.


Content continues below advertisement

» Popular Pages

  • Tickers
  • Articles

Jun 05

The Diversified Approach to Investing in the AI Sector

Jun 05

World Markets Watchlist: June 5

Jun 05

Direct Indexing Can Do What ETFs Can’t

Jun 05

Don't Miss These 4 Benefits in Pan-Asian Dividends

Jun 05

NSPL Dampens Volatility and Prepares Portfolios for a Recession

Jun 05

Look Down the Cap Spectrum for Opportunities in Industrials Sector

Jun 05

NYSE’s ETF Leaders: Trevor Terrell of Innovator ETFs

Jun 05

AI Innovation ETF WTAI’s AUM Doubles in a Week

Jun 05

Top-Performing ETFs: Crypto Funds in the Lead Again

Jun 05

Being a Trans-Friendly Financial Advisor

QQQ

Invesco QQQ Trust

SPY

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

JEPI

JPMorgan Equity Premium...

VTI

Vanguard Total Stock Market...

VOO

Vanguard S&P 500 ETF

VGT

Vanguard Information...

TLT

iShares 20+ Year Treasury...

BND

Vanguard Total Bond Market...

XLP

Consumer Staples Select...

BOTZ

Global X Robotics &...


Content continues below advertisement

Loading Articles...
Our Sites
  • VettaFi
  • Advisor Perspectives
  • ETF Trends
Tools
  • ETF Screener
  • Mutual Fund to ETF Converter
  • Head-To-Head ETF Comparison
  • ETF Country Exposure Tool
  • ETF Stock Exposure Tool
  • ETF Database Pro
More Tools
  • Financial Advisor & RIA Center
Explore ETFs
  • ETF News
  • ETF Category Reports
  • Premium Articles
  • Alphabetical Listing of ETFs
  • Browse ETFs by ETF Database Category
  • Browse ETFs by Index
  • Browse ETFs by Issuer
  • Compare ETFs
Information
  • Contact Us
  • Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
  • © 2023 VettaFi LLC. All rights reserved.

Advertisement

Is Your Portfolio Positioned With Enough Global Exposure?

ETF Education Channel

How to Allocate Commodities in Portfolios

Tom LydonApr 26, 2022
2022-04-26

A long-running debate in asset allocation circles is how much of a portfolio an investor should...

Core Strategies Channel

Why ETFs Experience Limit Up/Down Protections

Karrie GordonMay 13, 2022
2022-05-13

In a digital age where information moves in milliseconds and millions of participants can transact...

}
X