Megaphone icon ETF Database is now VettaFi. Read More >
ETFdb Logo
ETFdb Logo
  • ETF Database
  • Channels
    • Active ETF
    • Alternatives
    • Beyond Basic Beta
    • China Insights
    • Climate Insights
    • Commodities
    • Core Strategies
    • Crypto
    • Disruptive Technology
    • Dividend
    • Dual Impact
    • Emerging Markets
    • Energy Infrastructure
    • Entrepreneur ETF
    • Equity ETF
    • ESG
    • ETF Building Blocks
    • ETF Education
    • ETF Strategist
    • Fixed Income
    • Future ETFs
    • Gold & Silver Investing
    • Innovative ETFs
    • Institutional Income Strategies
    • Leveraged & Inverse
    • Managed Futures
    • Modern Alpha
    • Multi-Asset
    • Multi-Factor
    • Nasdaq Investment Intelligence
    • Portfolio Strategies
    • Retirement Income
    • Smart Beta
    • Thematic Investing
    • Volatility Resource
  • Tools
    • ETF Screener
    • ETF Country Exposure Tool
    • ETF Sector Tracker Tool
    • ETF Database Categories
    • Head-To-Head ETF Comparison Tool
    • ETF Stock Exposure Tool
    • ETF Issuer Fund Flows
    • Indexes
    • Mutual Fund To ETF Converter
    • ETF Data for Journalists
    • ETF Nerds
  • Research
    • First Bitcoin ETF
    • ETF Education
    • Equity Investing
    • Dividend ETFs
    • Leveraged ETFs
    • Inverse ETFs
    • Top ETF Sectors
    • Top ETF Issuers
    • Top ETF Industries
  • Webcasts
  • Themes
    • AI ETFs
    • Blockchain ETFs
    • See all Thematic Investing ETF themes
    • ESG Investing
    • Marijuana ETFs
  • Videos & Podcasts
    • ETF 360 Video Series
    • ETF Trends on Videos
    • ETF Trends on Podcasts
    • ETF Prime Podcast
  • PRO
    • Pro Content
    • Pro Tools
    • Advanced
    • FAQ
    • Pricing
    • Free Sign Up
    • Login
  1. Portfolio Management
  2. The Difference Between ETFs and Index Funds
Portfolio Management
Share

The Difference Between ETFs and Index Funds

Stoyan BojinovApr 24, 2015
2015-04-24

When categorizing various investment vehicles, most investors tend to think of mutual funds and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) as polar opposites.

Mutual funds are associated with active management, with a team of analysts and managers seeking to generate alpha by identifying undervalued securities from a relevant universe of stocks and bonds. ETFs, on the other hand, connote a passive investment strategy, products that seek to replicate the performance of a certain benchmark instead of seeking to beat it.

For those who believe that active management (or at least certain active managers) adds value, mutual funds may be preferred. For those who believe that it is impossible to consistently outperform markets, the lower-expense beta offered by ETFs are more attractive.

discussing investment strategies

While these classifications of mutual funds and ETFs are generally true–most mutual funds are actively-managed, and more expensive than passively-indexed ETFs–they certainly aren’t hard and fast rules of investing. There are, of course, actively-managed ETFs that utilize quantitative strategies and manager expertise to select individual holdings, much like most actively-managed mutual funds. And there are mutual funds that seek to passively replicate an index, exhibiting characteristics similar to traditional ETFs.

Be sure to see the 5 Charts to Put Mutual Fund Expenses in Perspective.

In reality, the true division is not between ETFs and mutual funds, but between active and passive. ETFs and mutual funds fall into both sides of that division.


Content continues below advertisement

ETFs vs. Index Funds: Similarities and Differences

Index mutual funds and passive ETFs are similar in a number of key ways. Most significantly, both seek to replicate the performance of underlying index. Although ETFs receive the bulk of the credit for the surge in popularity of indexing as an investment strategy, index mutual funds started the movement long before the first ETFs came to market. The Vanguard 500 Index Fund (VFINX), launched in 1976, is designed to track the return of the S&P 500, making it similar to the three ETFs that also seek to replicate the S&P 500.

Try our Free Mutual Fund to ETF Converter tool.

Because they seek not to generate alpha but to capture beta, index mutual funds are also similar to most ETFs in that they offer potential tax advantages resulting from lower turnover of underlying holdings. It also allows index mutual funds to charge low expense ratios that most investors associate with ETFs. The general assumption is often that all mutual funds maintain expense ratios significantly higher than ETFs.

While that’s generally true when comparing passive ETFs with actively-managed mutual funds–the industry average for mutual funds is somewhere in the neighborhood of 1.4%–it isn’t universally true. VFINX, for example, charges just 0.17%; while that’s three times the charge for VOO, it’s lower than most of the ETF universe.

So What’s The Difference?

comparing similar funds

The biggest difference between these two products is the frequency with which they are priced and traded. Index mutual funds are, after all, mutual funds, and as such they are priced once a day after markets close. ETFs–including both active and passive ETFs–are priced throughout the day, and can be bought or sold whenever the markets are open. Index mutual funds are priced based on the NAV of the underlying securities, whereas the price of an ETF depends on supply and demand for the security. Although the arbitrage mechanisms in place prevent ETF prices from deviating too significantly from the NAV, it is not uncommon for these securities to trade at a slight premium or discount.

So in exchange for the flexibility to trade throughout the day, investors who utilize ETFs may incur a bid-ask spread to establish or close out a position

See also Five Ways To Slash Your ETF Expenses.

Which To Use?

While index mutual funds and ETFs are similar in many ways, there are still some definite advantages to utilizing ETFs. The ability to trade ETFs at any time throughout the day–instead of having to wait until markets close to redeem at NAV–can be very valuable, especially in volatile environments. And while index mutual funds feature significantly lower costs than their actively-managed counterparts. The comparison between the mutual fund and ETF share classes of the Vanguard 500 Fund illustrate this quite well; as mentioned previously, VFINX charges 0.17%, while VOO charges just five basis points.

The primary advantages of index mutual funds, including the security of being able to execute buy and sell orders at the NAV, can be significant. Countless ETF investors have put themselves in a hole by buying at a big premium or selling at a big discount. But for those who know what they’re doing, the uncertainty associated with trading ETFs can generally be mitigated.

For more ETF insights, sign up for our free ETF newsletter.

Disclosure: No positions at time of writing.

» Popular Pages

  • Tickers
  • Articles

Jun 30

Are U.S. Equities Overrated?

Jun 30

RSP Increases On Utilities and Real Estate Gains

Jun 30

China Tech Stocks See Reconvened Buyer Interest

Jun 30

Grayscale Sues Over SEC’s Denial For Fund Conversion

Jun 30

Crypto Logs: Bitcoin ETFs and Index-Based Crypto ETFs

Jun 30

ETF of the Week: iMGP DBi Managed Futures Strategy ETF

Jun 30

LGBTQ Americans Less Confident Saving for Retirement

Jun 30

See Opportunity in China? CXSE Invests in Non-State-Owned Companies

Jun 30

BondBloxx Debuts Duration-Focused Emerging Market ETF

Jun 30

BlackRock Launches Investment Grade Corporate Bond ETF

QQQ

Invesco QQQ Trust

SPY

SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust

VOO

Vanguard S&P 500 ETF

TQQQ

ProShares UltraPro QQQ

ARKK

ARK Innovation ETF

SCHD

Schwab US Dividend Equity ETF...

VTI

Vanguard Total Stock Market...

XLE

Energy Select Sector SPDR...

VNQ

Vanguard Real Estate ETF

XLV

Health Care Select Sector...

Loading Articles...
Help & Info
  • Contact Us
  • Mission Statement
  • Press
Tools
  • ETF Screener
  • ETF Analyzer
  • Mutual Fund to ETF Converter
  • Head-To-Head ETF Comparison
  • ETF Country Exposure Tool
  • ETF Stock Exposure Tool
  • ETF Performance Visualizer
  • ETF Database Model Portfolios
  • ETF Database Realtime Ratings
  • ETF Database Pro
More Tools
  • ETF Launch Center
  • Financial Advisor & RIA Center
  • ETF Database RSS Feed
Explore ETFs
  • ETF News
  • ETF Picks of the Month
  • ETF Category Reports
  • Premium Articles
  • Alphabetical Listing of ETFs
  • Best ETFs
  • Browse ETFs by ETF Database Category
  • Browse ETFs by Index
  • Browse ETFs by Issuer
  • Compare ETFs
Legal
  • Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
  • © ETF Flows LLC
Follow ETF Database
Follow ETF Database

Advertisement

Is Your Portfolio Positioned With Enough Global Exposure?

ETF Education Channel

How to Allocate Commodities in Portfolios

Tom LydonApr 26, 2022
2022-04-26

A long-running debate in asset allocation circles is how much of a portfolio an investor should...

Core Strategies Channel

Why ETFs Experience Limit Up/Down Protections

Karrie GordonMay 13, 2022
2022-05-13

In a digital age where information moves in milliseconds and millions of participants can transact...

}
X